Welcome to Off Broadway Taproom
Off Broadway Taproom, nestled in the heart of Madison, IN, offers a cozy escape for food lovers and beer enthusiasts alike. Known for its welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, the taproom proudly serves up an array of mouthwatering burgers, tacos, and sandwiches, crafted from fresh, homemade ingredients. The vibrant menu includes options for everyone, from hearty tacos on special Tuesdays to refreshing salads bursting with flavor. The charming ambiance, paired with its focus on quality cuisine and local brews, ensures every visit is a memorable experience—one where flavors dance on your palate, and community spirit shines through.
-
218 E Main St, Madison, IN 47250 Hotline: (812) 274-0216
Welcome to **Off Broadway Taproom**, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Madison, Indiana, at 218 E Main St. This cozy establishment specializes in burgers and sandwiches, serving up delicious, homemade fare that caters to all tastes.
The atmosphere at Off Broadway Taproom exudes a friendly, small-town vibe, making it an ideal spot for families and couples alike. Patrons rave about the attentive service paired with a casual ambiance. As one satisfied customer aptly noted, "Walking in it felt like the kind of place you just knew was gonna be enjoyable." The combination of excellent food and service ensures a memorable dining experience, whether you are celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual meal with friends.
Now, let’s talk about the highlights of the menu that truly showcase culinary creativity:
- Appetizers: Start with the Hot Pretzels, complemented by house-made sharp cheddar beer cheese—an irresistible pairing at just $8.27. The Fried Green Tomatoes are another must-try, featuring hand-breaded, deep-fried slices served with remoulade. For a lighter option, opt for the Chips and Salsa, easily made vegan!
- Salads: If you're looking for a fresh option, the Greek Salad or Summer Salad offers vibrant flavors and generous toppings, all for $10.35. Adding blackened shrimp or chicken for just $3 more elevates your salad experience significantly.
- Tacos: On Taco Tuesdays and Sundays, savor delicious tacos for $3.38 each! From the hand-breaded fish taco to the hearty carnitas with fresh pineapple, there’s something for every palate. Don’t miss the Buffalo Chicken Taco, which packs a flavorful punch.
As you dive into your meal, enjoy a cold craft beer from their extensive tap selection, prominently featuring local breweries. Customers often highlight the refreshing brews as the perfect companion to their tasty dishes. One guest expressed, "The beer was ice cold; we’ll definitely be back!"
What stands out most about Off Broadway Taproom is its dedication to quality and customer care. Many reviews praise the made-from-scratch ethos; you can truly taste the difference in the homemade chips and dressings. "Everything is homemade in their kitchen," reflects one happy diner, emphasizing the restaurant's commitment to freshness.
In conclusion, Off Broadway Taproom is more than just a restaurant; it’s a gathering place filled with warmth, flavor, and community spirit. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely meal, you’ll likely leave with a full stomach and a big smile. Don’t miss out on this delightful haven in Madison! You’ll want to return time and time again.
For reservations, you can call them at (812) 274-0216.
Walked from our hotel based on a staff recommendation. Food was great, but service was even better. We can't wait to come back!
Walking in it felt like the kind of place you just knew was gonna be enjoyable, it was even better. Food was freaking delicious, service (with a minimal wait staff) was always there when needed, never a wait. The beer ice cold, a fun time for my wife and I on our anniversary. We will a DEFINITELY be back! She had the ribeye sandwich and I had the patty melt. The half loaded tater tot appetizer is knock your socks off delish!! Homemade ranch dressing so good you could pour it on a pair of flip flops and eat them! Well enough said, get anywhere close to here in Madison, you got to go!
Stopped in for dinner here one night while in town. They have bar seating and regular tables too. Inside was cozy. Our waitress was friendly and knowledgeable. Food was wonderful and our orders were correct. My burger was well seasoned, and the homemade chips were fresh and crisp. Would eat here again if ever in town. Even though it was getting busy (fri night) we were never rushed. Small town goodness!
My dad and I stopped here while passing through on a motorcycle trip. Very friendly service and many beer taps from Illinois breweries. We had the smoked wings, which were very good. The taco salad was very good but the spring greens got lost in the ground beef. I would suggest Romain lettuce instead of spring greens. I highly recommend.!
We had the best service and lunch at this cute establishment. We passed by it twice before we found it because the outside street sign was missing. We had a wonderful server who was very familiar with the menu and made recommendations. Everything is homemade in their kitchen. Thomas enjoyed wings and two tacos. I had the VEGAN black bean and mushroom burger with a side salad. The burger and salad were excellent and filled me up as the portions were generous. I was so thrilled to see at least 4 vegan options on the menu. The restaurant is older but clean and well maintained. The bathrooms are as well. I would definitely return and I highly recommend it.
It was a slow start to a Saturday morning. We were walking and saw the Off Broadway Taproom. We weren't in the door a half a minute and were greeted by the bartender, the hostess, and one family sitting down to eat their breakfast. Love the small-town charm! Our server was an absolute charmer, and even though he was busy, he took the time to make sure we knew what we were getting, as well as some of the specials they were offering. I had decided on my selection twice before he came over and I wound up changing it again after he came over! My wife ordered the Salmon Eggs Benedict, and I went with the Chicken & Waffles. Now, I'm not shorting the Chicken & Waffles - they were simply amazing - but she let me taste that blackened salmon with the hollandaise and oh my goodness did she ever win breakfast! Next time we're in town, you can bet we're eating at the Off Broadway Taproom!
We went on taco Tuesday. The tacos are unbelievably delicious and huge. They were all great. I liked the Carnitas best. Violet took care of us. She really hustled. I like the hydro racer on the back wall. Cool decoration. Definitely deserves 5 stars. They need more tables.
Stopped in Off Broadway Taproom on a rainy day to get a little lunch. They were pretty busy at noon on Saturday. My hubby had the Wee Mac in a can for his drink and I chose a Coke. They waited on us pretty quickly and checked on us a couple of time during the meal. I ordered fried green tomatoes and the Philly cheesesteak sandwich, the hubby ordered wings with two different sauces. I chose the house-made chips for my side with the Philly. Pretty cool bar area and it was busy as well. We enjoyed our meal and appreciated the quick service. I would order the Philly again as it was a good amount of food and tasty.